A practical solution?
Mid-Hudson Valley residents are no strangers to powerful storms that bring strong winds, rain and heavy snow that topple trees, block roads and interrupt electric service. Some have suggested placing electric utility lines underground as a way to avoid power outages that may result from severe weather. However, there are serious concerns in burying the many thousands of miles of overhead electric transmission and distribution lines that serve our region.
Perhaps the most significant challenge of undergrounding is its cost, estimated to be about $18 billion for the system that serves the Mid-Hudson Valley. This would have a major impact on the price of electric service, permanently adding an average of more than $10,000 per customer per year to existing utility bills, a cost which residents and businesses would no doubt find intolerable. Also, underground lines are not immune to outages due to environmental conditions, are more expensive to maintain, and are five to ten times more expensive to replace or upgrade when that should become necessary.
Environmental impact and logistical difficulties
There are many logistical issues, too. Streams, wetlands and environmentally sensitive areas along roadsides must be crossed; transformers and other facilities now located on top of poles must be relocated on the ground, almost always on private property; residents would be required to have their electrician install an underground service line at their own expense, typically $2,000 for residences and potentially much more for businesses; and telephone and cable television companies would also have to bury their lines, which carries an additional high cost.
Trees near underground lines would have to be completely removed, as root systems will impact lines and hinder future access. Power outages, when they do occur, will take much longer to find and repair, possibly weeks.
Sensible in some situations
Underground utility lines do make sense in specific cases, such as densely populated urban areas and, as required by state law, in new residential developments, where the installation can take place together with road construction, and site excavation work financed by the developer. However, converting the existing overhead systems to underground is not in the best interest of our customers.
Central Hudson continues to invest in the electric distribution and transmission system each year, and follows a comprehensive vegetation management program. Even when considering major storms, our customers' electric service reliability averages better than 99.9 percent.
|UNDERGROUND SERVICE - FACTS AT A GLANCE|
|INCREASED COSTS VS. COST SAVINGS|
|Underground system installation costs:||
· Distribution lines: 7,300 miles @ $1.6 million per mile: $12 billion
|Annual underground maintenance costs:||
$5 million per year
|Cost savings with undergrounding:||
· Tree trimming and storm-related costs: $18 million per year
|Net increased cost to customers of undergrounding:||
Approximate annual revenue requirement: $3.24 billion per year
|Additional customer costs:||
One-time fee for underground service line, provided by electrician: $2,000 per residence (higher for businesses); Telephone and cable television line would also have to be buried, at an additional high cost.
|RELIABILITY OF CURRENT OVERHEAD SYSTEM|
|With major storms:||99.92 percent reliability|
|Without major storms:||99.96 percent reliability|